Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts

Monday, November 28, 2011

I feel sorry for the minister of finance

Vítor Gaspar
He just seems such a nice guy.  He speaks clearly and is clearly no real politician...yet.  He is also is nearly the only member of government (or even parliament) that actually seems to be able to calm down the country.  In spite of his job of delivering the extreme austerity measures.  If his measures had the same quality as their delivery, things would start to look brighter.

But boy does he look aged and stressed.

Anybody would, with his responsibility.  And his problems - they become worse every day...

The OECD just came out with new previsions from their group of Gypsy soothsayers.  I don't know why but I trust their gypsies more the the gypsies of the EU not to mention the complete lack of quality of the Portuguese soothsayers.

Retraction of the economy will be worse in 2012 than predicted by the government about 4 weeks ago and worse than predicted by the EU about 3 weeks ago: Not 2,8%, not 3% but 3,2%.

My hat eating, as fun as it would be, looks more unlikely than ever.  Of course you do not need a soothsayer to be able to predict that it will worse than 3,2%.  Much worse, I am afraid.

That is what a lot of new taxes and no structural changes will do to a country like Portugal.  In fact we still have to see a single structural change implemented to try to make it possible or even likely for businesses to grow.  They are the producers.  The simple truth is that we all live off the products of what looks like a smaller group of smaller producers in 2012 and onwards.  Not the least because the consumers will have less purchasing power in Portugal for sure, and probably in the entire EU.  Even with the same purchase power, people are saving more and are more careful with spending.

By the way, the OECD also predicts nearly 14% unemployment for 2013.   Higher numbers than the government and the EU predict.   We will be lucky if it does not rise to the Greek levels of this year.  Estimated at 18%.  

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

The street is a cold place to sleep

The government, the Bank of Portugal, the Central Bank of Europe, the OECD and other agencies ad nauseam all predict, conditions considered, a rather low contraction of the Portuguese economy for 2012.  The government found the number 2.8% in la-la land and are suprisingly the official pessimists.  In 2013 they bet on growth - it has been visualized in the smoke of the hash pipes and been confirmed by the government chief astrologer.

I will eat my old hat if it does not become much worse.

Several sources today (here is one) can inform us about a rising number of people and families not being able to pay their mortgage. One number advanced is 500% (this source is left wing and does exaggerate a little).   However, it is evident that lower income and the rising unemployment make a mortgage crisis to be expected.

Several of the sources agree we are talking about currently 668000 people who are behind.  122 are added every day.  My source de jour claims 140000 families have stopped paying for good.

And the real austerity measures have not even been implemented yet.  

Pray do explain, how many more do you think that will be at the end of next year?   Maybe I am not the brightest light in the blogosphere, but I do not understand the government budget or the economy forecast.  Are you betting on creating additional demand by building half a million new houses and filling them with furniture?  Or are you going to bail out the banks?  Are you going to pay the mortgages for the unemployed?

To entrepeneurs:  I foresee a business opportunity in blankets.

When I started working in Lisbon 20 years ago, it was common early in the morning to see children sleeping on the warm air vents of the metro in the street.  At the time, a police commander in Lisbon was quoted "there are 1000 children living in the streets of Lisbon".  This horrible problem was solved, I presume, as you do not see children living in the street anymore.  But if the politicians do not get their act together - it will happen again.

Update 10.11.2011: The European commission are already counting with -3% growth in 2012.  Already the government estimates are being questioned.  And my hat eating looks even more unlikely.  When the estimates are over 5% - then I might start giving them some credibility.  We will be lucky if that is all...

Saturday, October 29, 2011

I beg you

Shooting yourself in the foot may be deadly.  Don't do it.
PM Passos Coelho, Hat Tip (Fernando Campos)

A priori this government sounds like it want to make the necessary changes.  In Brazil the PM yesterday stated:

"Our path we have to follow is a path of economic change, we must bet more on the companies, more on the opening on the economy to the exterior, more on entrepreneurship and the creativity of the Portuguese, free us from the weight of this debt - it will take time, but has to be done, to reduce the spending of the state and the public expenses"


DUH!

We need to solve the structural problems.  Indeed!   But when you look at what the government is doing it is astoundingly limited.  Let us study what is being done for the companies.  Here are the plans:

  1. Workers in the private sector will work 2.5 hours more per week with no compensation
  2. 4-5 yearly holidays will be abolished, and bridges will be eliminated.
Is that it?  No lower costs? No incentives?  No smaller public sector?  No lower labor costs?  No more efficiency?  No less bureaucracy?  No better education?  No better health? No lower social costs?  No economic help?  No way to get loans/finance?  No more liberal labour laws?  No more work force mobility?  

I could be generous and list a few initiatives that may be the beginning of structural change and perhaps a lower level of expenditure for the public sector:
  1. Less PPPs, public private entity co-operations
  2. Privatization of large public companies
  3. Abolishing a large number of public entities
    But which, and is abolishment just joining them together into larger fewer ones?
    There are no plans to fire any public employees (as the immediate cost would be larger than the savings)
  4. Cutting health costs
  5. Cutting education costs
  6. Making former free highways not so
No, the government has instead insisted on creating income on the short term to live up to the public sector maximum deficit as defined by the Troika.   Because the alternative is bankruptcy as Portugal would default.  But would this really be so bad?  Greece has technically defaulted now and will be forgiven 50% of its debt.  I checked a recent satellite image and Greece is still there.   

I am very afraid the cure proposed by the PSD government is as bad or worse than the decease - if possible

Consider some of the measures Portugal will have to live with:
  • Higher income tax for well to do companies
  • Higher income tax for well to do people
  • Less deductions income tax for all individuals and especially for well to do individuals = more tax
  • Higher property taxes
  • Higher levels of value added tax.  The max level has been raised from 16% to 23% percent the last few years.  This government does not raise the max level, but it will raise some lower level taxed products from 6% and 13% to 23%.
    Here are some where it will hurt:  Restaurants, cafes, entertainment, electricity and gas
  • All, except the poorest, retirees (except for people associated with the devil) will loose two monthly payments per year (the 13th and 14th) for at least the next two years
  • All, except the worst paid, public employees will loose two monthly payments per year (the 13th and 14th) for at least the next two years
  • Everybody, except the poorest, will loose 3,5% of their income this year in extra tax. (50% taxation of the 14th salary)
  • No pensions will be actualized the next two years (at least)
  • No public salaries will be actualized the next two years (at least)
  • Cutting health costs
  • Cutting education costs
  • Demanding higher levels of bank reserves
  • Raising costs of public transports
The year is not over yet and we will see more measures still.  2012 and 2013 will see more yet.

I could also list what the government is not doing.  But my keyboard would not be able to handle the massive input.

Anyway, the consequences read somewhat like an economics 101 recipe for disaster:
  • When people have less money to spend - they spend less.  Currently half of everybody in Portugal earn less 500 euros per month.
  • When products become more expensive (e.g. more VAT) people buy less
  • When people spend less, the companies sell less
  • When companies sell less, they earn less or go broke
  • When companies sell less and go broke unemployment will worsen. .
  • My schadenfreude is vibrant on the news of public employees loosing income.  A large group of them, the bureaucrats, deserve it.  But less income to a large group of the population means, all things even, also a retraction of the economy.  They will spend less
  • A retraction of the economy leads, all things even, to less well to do companies and individuals
  • You may have noticed that I added cutting health costs on both the list of the structural change measures and the list above.  Please do show me a single economy where lowering health levels have lead to more richness?  Sick people do not work very well and they are expensive in the long run.  They are even more expensive when they can not be fired
  • You may have noticed that I added cutting education costs on both the list of the structural change measures and the list above.  Please do show me a single economy where lowering educations levels have lead to more richness?  Stupid people are not much good in countries which are dependent on high tech industries and they are expensive in the long run.  They are even more expensive when they cannot be fired.  Stupid people tend to be worse citizens than educated people.
  • Retroactive (ex post facto) laws are not popular or even illegal for a reason.  You tend to distrust when words are broken and how can you have a society of law and justice when your current lawful, maybe even recommended, actions may be illegal tomorrow?   Cutting pensions are surely a necessity, but it is also a retroactive measure.  The current retirees have for the most part paid large shares (generally speaking 34+%) of the money reserved for them as salaries, subsidies, and social costs for their retirements mostly in the form of social security.  They were guaranteed a certain pension.  So much for that promise.
  • The banks are currently hardly financing any companies.  They will after raising reserves have even less to lend.
  • Added costs for companies, such as higher property taxes and added transportation costs, does not exactly help the bottom line.
The consumer confidence index is nearing the lowest ever.  The unemployment at the highest level in recent times.

IMHO the government measures are nearly all making it more difficult for the private sector.  It will diminish.  There will be less companies, less income, and less entrepreneurship.   The economy will retract.

In Greece by now 20% of all shops have closed.  I am sure soon at least 20% of all other companies will have closed as well.  And it will hurt much more next year and probably the coming years...   In Portugal the same will happen.   When it does, we are not talking about 13% unemployment but rather 20 something percent.  The Spanish unemployment is currently at 21,5%, youth unemployment over 40%.  I am afraid our neighbor with a seemingly more healthy economy is showing us where we are going.

The real tragedy here is that the government when proposing its measures had certain assumptions like:  13% unemployment and a retraction of the economy of 2,8% for 2012.  (I am not certain of the exact numbers and too lazy to look them up - but they are in that neighborhood).   Everybody outside the government just knows it will be worse!

I beg you.  Somebody give the government a calculator!

For the possible consequences could be devastating.  Worst scenarios consists of decades of crisis, 30% or more unemployed, education and health sectors in ruin and private enterprise destroyed.

In the above the focus is mostly on economic issues.  But this is not really where the focus ought only to be.  Economy, or money, is just a means, albeit important, to accomplish something.  A thriving economy is not a guarantee for a thriving population.  What is to guarantee life quality, satisfaction and happiness?  A recent study pins Portuguese as some of the most unhappy of the OECD.

A huge unemployment is surely not a way to improve happiness.

I beg you.  Somebody ask the government to get their priorities in order.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Economy, reality and perception of politicians all together

In the House of Hens
Hat tip: Ekstra Bladet (Danish tabloid) and Ingemann (cartoonist)

Translation from left to right:

If I need 50 grams of fodder to make an egg of 50 grams...

What do I then need to make an egg of 100 grams...

A larger asshole...

Who said asshole...Are you once more speaking about him the Minister of Food...

Brilliant provoking cartoonist.  Thank you.